Sonny Gray or Jose Quintana?

According to MLB Network’s Jon Morosi, the Brewers are preparing to buy at the Trade Deadline and have begun to look into starting pitchers Sonny Gray, Jose Quintana, and others. Well Brewers fans, David Stearns has officially change his mind. The Brewers general manager originally said that the team would be sticking to the plan and continuing its rebuild until this mornings report. So who should it be? Sonny Gray? Jose Quintana? Someone else? I have seen other sources saying one of the “other” pitchers could be Toronto’s J.A. Happ.

If you look at both Gray and Quintana’s numbers, there isn’t a lot of difference between the two. Both have had good numbers on bad baseball teams their whole career. Their career ERAs both sit around 3.50, they both strikeout about the same number of batters per season, and play in the American League, which means they deal with the designated hitter.

If I’m David Stearns and got to chose which of these two I wanted, I’d be on team Quintana.  Jose Quintana, 28, is a year older than Sonny Gray,  but at the same time is six years younger than J.A. Happ. He has also been a more consistent pitcher in his career than Gray has. Quintana is in his sixth season in the big leagues and has logged over 200 innings four times in his career and is on pace to do so again this season. In comparison, Gray has only thrown over 200 innings twice in his career. Quintana has also never had a major injury in his career, while Gray has been plagued by injuries since 2015. Gray is also a smaller pitcher as he goes 5’10” and 190 pounds and smaller pitchers have had durability issues like Tim Lincecum.

Both guys would be under team control for the next two seasons. Gray is eligible for arbitration after this season for the next couple of years and should be due to make more money than his current 3.5 million dollar contract. Quintana’s contract would leave the Brewers on the hook for 8.8 million next year, and a club option for 2019 and 2020 for 10.5 million. The difference in the two salaries shouldn’t really matter as the Brewers have the lowest payroll in the MLB.

To me, Gray is the boom or bust move here. Both guys are number two starters on a pitching staff when healthy. Gray also has been dealing with nagging injuries the past couple years, but has the ceiling to be an ace in my opinion. When Gray’s been good, he’s been good, but he has been injury prone. I don’t want the Brewers to be buyers this deadline and trade away prospects for an injury prone pitcher. Quintana is the clear cut choice for me in this situation because you know what you’re getting. The Brewers would be getting a solid starting pitcher who is durable and would be a great compliment to Chase Anderson and Jimmy Nelson. Quintana has quietly finished in the top-10 in AL Cy Young voting multiple times in his career.

Brewers drop second straight to Cardinals

The free fall continues for the Milwaukee Brewers as they have dropped eight out of the last 11 games and for the first time in quite sometime find themselves on the outside looking in at the playoff picture. Saturday night brought another loss to the St. Louis Cardinals, this one by a score of 7-2. […]


Brewers drop series opener to Cardinals

The Milwaukee Brewers had not been more than four games outside of the division lead all season until Friday night. After the Brewers lost to the St. Louis Cardinals 5-2 on the road, they dropped to 4 1/2 games behind the division leading Chicago Cubs. Furthermore, the team’s grasp on playoff positioning overall has started […]


Brewers settle for split with Chicago

Milwaukee had to settle for a split of its quick two-game series with Chicago. Like the Brewers did on Tuesday, the Cubs jumped out to an early lead and were barely challenged the rest of the way in an 8-4 victory at Wrigley Field. Junior Guerra took the brunt of the punishment, giving up a […]


Jimmy Nelson unlikely to pitch for Brewers in 2018

It’s likely that the Brewers will be without starting pitcher Jimmy Nelson for the entirety of the 2018 season, Milwaukee manager Craig Counsell said on Wednesday. Nelson’s 2017 season was cut short due to a shoulder injury that occurred when he dove into first base during a game against the Chicago Cubs last September. He […]


Brewers beat the Cubs, back to within 2 games of NL Central lead

The Milwaukee Brewers got their biggest week of the season off to a great start Tuesday afternoon with a 7-0 win over the Chicago Cubs at Wrigley Field. Manager Craig Counsell’s club jumped on Chicago starter Jose Quintana right away. They got a leadoff home run from Lorenzo Cain and then a two-run shot from […]


Report: Brewers prepared to be buyers at the trade deadline

Milwaukee’s surprising success this season has reportedly turned the team into potential buyers at the MLB trade deadline.

According to MLB Network’s Jon Morosi, the Brewers have begun background work on several starting pitchers, including the White Sox’s Jose Quintana and Sonny Gray of the Athletics.

The Brewers starting pitching has been solid this season, even with injuries knocking Junior Guerra, Matt Garza and Chase Anderson out for extended periods of time. As of Friday, the starters ERA was 4.09, ranking seventh in the majors.

As for the guys the team is reportedly looking at, the 27-year-old Gray is 4-4 with a 4.00 ERA and is in the final year of his contract, while the 28-year-old Quintana is just 4-8 on the season with a 4.45 ERA and he’s got two years left on his deal.

Thought to still be a few years away from contending, the Brewers are 48-40 and own a 4.5 game lead in the NL Central.

The trade deadline is July 31.